Why I’m Done Buying Cookie Cutters (And You Should Be Too)

What am I doing instead of buying cookie cutters?

Alright, let’s get real for a second. I’m officially breaking up with cookie cutters. Yep, you heard that right. It’s over. No more scrolling through cookie cutters on Etsy or impulse buying another set of "adorable" shapes I’ll only use once. I’ve learned a few hard truths over the last year, and now, I’m ready to spill the tea. Spoiler alert: it’s about saving my budget, saving the planet, and ultimately, saving my sanity.

Cookie Cutters Are Cute, But...

I’ve spent almost $500 on cookie cutters this past year alone. That’s right, five hundred bucks! And while 3D cookie cutters made of plastic are cute and all, they’re not doing my wallet any favors.

Let’s not even talk about the fact that most of these cutters are one-trick ponies.

I buy one for a specific design (because, obviously, that snowman needs the perfect scarf shape), and then it sits in my drawer, collecting dust. Sure, it looks great in photos, but is it worth the price tag? Nope.

The Not-So-Sweet Side of 3D Cookie Cutters

Let’s talk about 3D cookie cutters for a second. While some of them are awesome, not all are created equal. I haven't had any that are dishwasher safe—learned that lesson the hard way! One was accidently tossed into the dishwasher, and well, let’s just say it came out looking like a modern art sculpture. Melted. Beyond. Use.

And even if you take care of them, they’re made of plastic. That’s not exactly great for the environment, and it's definitely not sustainable. Plus, constantly buying new ones just adds to the waste.

My Almost 3D Printer Debacle

At one point, I seriously thought about getting a 3D printer. I know, I know... I thought I’d be my own cookie cutter manufacturer. But here’s the thing: 3D printers are expensive!

The cheapest model I was looking at was still several hundred dollars. And let’s not forget the ongoing cost of the plastic filament—which still doesn’t solve the environmental issue. It’s like trading one problem for another.

Plus, do I really need another creative gadget? Probably not. I certainly don't have the time to start over on a whole new learning-curve adventure, which is what I've heard about most 3d printers.

Cookie Cutters Are Plastic, and My Wallet Can’t Take It

I mean, who knew a baking hobby could turn into such a money pit? With all the designs, I found myself constantly buying more cutters.

Halloween? New cutters. Valentine’s Day? More cutters. Every season, every event... it just kept adding up.

I didn’t even want to think about cookie cutters prices anymore, but my bank account had a thing or two to say. And honestly? My storage drawers were full, too. Trying to figure out how to store cookie cutters without a kitchen takeover is another headache.

Time to Get Smart: Royal Icing Transfers to the Rescue!

So, what’s the solution? Royal icing transfers! Instead of spending all that money on cutters, I’ve switched to using royal icing transfers that I can make ahead of time and just pop onto cookies. They save me so much time (and money!), plus they’re way easier to store. And the best part? They can be just as detailed and creative without the constant need for a new shape.

Join Me: Let’s Do This Together!

If you’re tired of blowing cash on cookie cutters and want to try something new, I’ve got you covered. You can get trendy, on-point royal icing transfers delivered to your door every month with my Trendy Mint Monthly Subscription. Each month, I’ll send you exclusive templates that reflect the latest trends, so you can stay on top of your cookie game without breaking the bank.

Think of it as a way to join forces for good. Less plastic, more creativity, and way more budget-friendly. It’s all about working smarter, not harder. And if you're still on the cookie cutters reviews pages, I say close the tab, friend, and let’s make this switch together.

And best of all, it's not $500! AND you get way more than what a few cookie cutters can offer. Each month contains a newsletter with info on all the latest trends, a personal letter from yours truly, a tried and true cookie recipe that will knock your socks off, a list of fun family activities (we know if you're a baker, you have to make that time count), TEN Royal Icing Transfer Template Sheets plus BONUSES every single month!

(Scroll to the bottom of the page to get a discount on your first month)

Bottom Line

Cookie cutters are plastic, expensive, and, quite frankly, a hassle. Between the environmental impact and the hit to my budget, I’ve decided enough is enough. It’s time to get creative with transfers and ditch the cutter obsession.

Let’s leave the cookie-cutter purchases in the past and start something more sustainable—for our wallets, our planet, and our businesses. You in?